AI marketing agency · Buying guide

How to Choose an AI Marketing Agency: 10 Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Every agency pitch now mentions AI. These ten questions get past the pitch to how the work is actually done, who is accountable and what happens if it does not work out.

Ajay Kumar • •7 min read
Illustration of a checklist label for choosing an agency

Quick answer: how do you choose an AI marketing agency?

Ask what the AI does and what people do, who approves changes, how they fix tracking, how they measure new customers and profit, who checks AI creative, who owns the accounts, and what the trial and exit terms are. Score each answer, ask for an anonymised report and change log, and run a three-month trial.

Why the usual agency questions are not enough

"How many clients do you have?" and "What results have you got?" still matter, but with AI in the mix you also need to know how the work is split between software and people. For the basics, see our guide to what an AI marketing agency is.

What you are trying to learn

Three things: whether their process will get results for a brand like yours, whether you will see clearly what they do, and whether you can leave cleanly if it does not work. The ten questions below are grouped around those three goals, and each comes with what a good and a weak answer usually sounds like.

Questions 1 to 5: how the work is done

1. Which jobs does your AI do, and which do people do?

Good answer: a specific list, such as daily monitoring and report drafts by software, budget decisions and creative briefs by a named person. Weak answer: "Our proprietary AI handles everything."

2. Who approves changes to my account, and what are the limits?

Good answer: changes above a set size, for example a 20% budget move, need approval; everything is logged. Weak answer: "We optimise continuously."

3. What do you do in the first two weeks?

Good answer: a tracking audit, checking that Meta's Conversions API with deduplication and Google's enhanced conversions are set up, and agreeing margins and targets. Weak answer: launching new campaigns on day one.

4. How do you measure success?

Good answer: cost per new customer and profit after ad spend from your store data, alongside platform numbers. Weak answer: ROAS screenshots only. Independent data from Wicked Reports found the new-customer acquisition cost on Meta Advantage+ more than doubled in a year, which ROAS alone would hide.

5. Who checks AI-generated creative?

Good answer: a named person reviews every version for claims, prices and product accuracy. Meta's documentation on generative AI features says advertisers are responsible for previewing AI creative before it runs. Weak answer: "The AI is brand-safe."

Questions 6 to 10: accountability and exit

6. Who exactly works on my account, and how many accounts do they handle?

Good answer: names, roles and a realistic account load. Weak answer: "Our team."

7. How often will I get reports, and what is in them?

Good answer: weekly, with spend, results, cost per new customer, profit, changes made and next steps. Ask for an anonymised sample.

8. Who owns the ad accounts, pixels and creative files?

Good answer: you do; the agency gets partner access. Weak answer: they will create new accounts under their business.

9. How does your fee change as my spend grows?

Good answer: a clear table. Watch for percentage-of-spend fees that grow regardless of results.

10. What are the trial and exit terms?

Good answer: a defined trial with targets, a short notice period and a handover checklist. Weak answer: a long lock-in with no targets.

Score the answers

Score each question 0 to 2: 0 = vague or worrying, 1 = acceptable, 2 = specific and backed by evidence.

AreaQuestionsWeight
Process and AI use1, 2, 3Normal
Measurement and creative checks4, 5, 7Double
People and fees6, 9Normal
Ownership and exit8, 10Double

Worked example: two agencies scored

The scores

Agency A scores 2 on questions 1, 3, 4, 7 and 8, 1 on the rest. Agency B scores 2 on 1, 2 and 9, 1 on 3, 5, 6 and 10, and 0 on 4, 7 and 8.

Weighted totals

Double-weight questions: 4, 5, 7, 8 and 10. Maximum = 10 questions × 2 + 5 double questions × 2 = 30.

Weighted score = sum of scores + sum of scores on double-weight questions

Agency A: 15 + (2 + 1 + 2 + 2 + 1) = 23 of 30. Agency B: 10 + (0 + 1 + 0 + 0 + 1) = 12 of 30.

Agency B gave a strong pitch on AI and fees but failed on measurement, reporting and ownership. Agency A is the safer choice, even though its fee is slightly higher.

Ask for evidence, not promises

  1. An anonymised weekly report from a current client.
  2. An anonymised change log showing what software flagged and what a person decided.
  3. Two references from brands at a similar size, ideally in your category.
  4. A sample creative brief and the ads made from it.
  5. The draft contract, including notice period and data ownership clauses.

Many of the same checks apply to software; see our 10 questions before buying an AI ad tool. If you are still deciding between an agency and doing it yourself, read AI agency versus AI platform.

Signals to watch during the pitch

Good signs

Warning signs

Trust your notes

Write down the answers during each call. Comparing notes across two or three agencies a week later is far more reliable than remembering which pitch felt best.

Contract points that protect you

Ownership

Ad accounts, pixels, catalogues, creative files and reports belong to your company.

Approval limits

Budget changes above an agreed size, new campaigns and any change in targeting rules need your written approval.

Exit

A notice period of about one month after the trial, removal of agency access on exit and a handover of all files and logs.

Keep a shared change log

Ask for every change to be written in a log you can see. It is the simplest way to understand results and to hand over cleanly if you ever switch.

What most agency checklists tend to get wrong

They ask about tools, not decisions

The software matters less than who decides what and how fast.

They accept ROAS as proof

Ask for cost per new customer and profit from your own store data.

They forget the exit

Ownership and notice terms decide how painful a bad choice becomes. Compare agency types in our guide to AI-first versus traditional agencies.

Disclosure

ScaleWin, our product, is an AI platform for Meta and Google Ads. These questions work for any agency or platform, including us.

Key takeaways

  • Ask for specifics: which jobs the AI does, which people do, and who approves changes.
  • Good agencies start with tracking and measure new customers and profit, not just platform ROAS.
  • Someone must check every AI-generated creative before it runs.
  • Accounts, pixels and creative files must stay in your name.
  • Score answers, ask for evidence and agree a trial with clear exit terms.

Ai marketing agency: frequently asked questions

What should I ask an AI marketing agency first?

Ask which jobs their AI does and which people do, and who approves changes to your account. Specific answers with named people and clear limits are a good sign; vague claims that the AI handles everything are not.

How do I know if an agency really uses AI well?

Ask for an anonymised change log showing what software flagged and what a person decided, plus a sample weekly report. Good use of AI shows up as faster, more frequent and clearer work, not as a buzzword in the pitch.

Who should own my ad accounts when I hire an agency?

Your company. Ad accounts, pixels, catalogues and creative files should be in your name, with the agency given partner access. That way you keep your data and history if you change agencies.

What results should an agency report?

Spend, results, cost per new customer and profit after ad spend from your store data, plus changes made and next steps. Platform ROAS is useful for comparing campaigns but should not be the only measure.

Is it a red flag if an agency guarantees results?

Usually yes. Results depend on your product, price, stock and offer as well as ads, so an honest agency cannot guarantee sales or ROAS before seeing your data. Look for clear targets, transparent reporting and fair exit terms instead.

How long should an agency trial last?

About three months with written targets measured against the previous three months. Campaigns need time to settle after a handover, so one month is usually too short to judge fairly.

Sources

Ajay Kumar
Founder, ScaleWin · 12+ years in performance marketing

Ajay is the founder of ScaleWin. He works hands-on with Meta Ads, Google Ads and SEO for Indian D2C and service brands, and built ScaleWin so that the daily work of a performance marketer - reading numbers, pausing losers, scaling winners - happens automatically.

Drafted with AI assistance. How these articles are written

Let ScaleWin read your ad data every day

ScaleWin checks your Meta and Google Ads daily, judges every ad on profit and tells you exactly what to change.

Start free, no card

Get marketing tips that grow your business

One practical email a week on ads, SEO and growth. No spam, no fluff. Unsubscribe anytime.